The Colts have had one of the most unwatchable quarterback battles of the summer leading into the regular season. On Tuesday, Daniel Jones emerged as the starter over Anthony Richardson, who is heading into a critical, prove-it type season. However, suffering a minor injury in Week 1 of the preseason didn’t do Richardson any favors.
“Jones didn't necessarily outplay Richardson in two preseason games, but the former Giant did remain healthy throughout spring practice and training camp, while Richardson has dealt with shoulder and finger injuries. There's still a good chance Richardson eventually makes starts this season, given Jones' shaky track record with the Giants,” CBS Sports wrote.
Richardson was expected to turn things around this year. After all, this may be his last opportunity to prove to the Colts that he can be the franchise quarterback they believed they were drafting.
“So, if there was ever a time for Richardson to put the pieces together in his development as a pro quarterback, now is certainly the moment to present that before he finds himself at risk of losing his starting job,” Sports Illustrated’s Jared Koch wrote.
Former NFL head coach Bruce Arians expressed doubts earlier this summer, saying he didn’t believe Richardson had developed enough in college.
“Anthony, I think needed two more years of college... as a passer. I didn’t see him being able to beat anybody in 2-minute & 3rd down. If you can’t do that in the NFL you’re just an average guy,” Arians said.
Follow The Sporting News on WhatsApp
Former NFL quarterback Kurt Benkert also weighed in, relying on film for his evaluation. He believes Richardson was never truly ready.
“This whole Anthony Richardson thing is why when I do my analysis on here I lean in on film. Film doesn’t lie and eventually things play out as they should. I hope he gets a fresh start somewhere else and can learn and reinvent himself as a QB. He has the talent - he wasn’t ready,” Benkert posted.
Richardson was once one of the most sought-after quarterbacks in his draft class. Now, that no longer appears to be the case. Instead, he may be heading toward a future as a backup or third-stringer, bouncing between rosters. If Jones does falter, Richardson will need to do more than stay healthy — he’ll have to produce and prove he still belongs.