The College Football Playoff is supposed to be predictable. The bluebloods—Georgia, Ohio State, Texas, Penn State—command the spotlight before the first snap is even played. But in this second year of the 12-team CFP, the shadows are alive with possibility. New names, fresh narratives, and unexpected heroes are ready to step out of the margins and write themselves into history.
Here are five dark horse programs with the power, talent, and timing to shake the college football landscape to its core.
Arizona State Sun Devils (Big 12)
The desert is no longer barren. Under Kenny Dillingham, Arizona State has transformed from a rebuilding project into a Big 12 contender. QB Sam Leavitt is the triggerman for an offense that thrives on speed and chaos, while the defense—once a liability—now returns enough pieces to be opportunistic. In a wide-open Big 12 where Texas and Oklahoma have moved on, the Sun Devils carry the scent of disruption.
The playoff path: Win shootouts at home, avoid an early stumble, and peak in November. In a league desperate for a new identity, Arizona State could seize the crown.
Illinois Fighting Illini (Big Ten)
Illinois doesn’t win on flash. They win with toughness, trench play, and a system that refuses to bend. QB Luke Altmyer returns alongside a loaded offensive line and one of the nation’s most veteran rosters (16 returning starters). Brett Bielema has built the Illini into a physical Big Ten team that thrives in low-scoring slugfests—exactly the kind of football that flips CFP rankings upside down.
The playoff path: Survive September, steal a statement win against Ohio State, and finish 10–2. With the Big Ten now commanding automatic CFP bids, Illinois could be this year’s iron-willed gate crasher.
© Eric Seals via Imagn Content Services, LLC
Michigan Wolverines (Big Ten)
Strange to call Michigan a dark horse after back-to-back playoff trips—but in 2025, the Wolverines are an afterthought compared to Penn State and Ohio State. That’s dangerous. QB Alex Orji provides the dynamic rushing spark, and Sherrone Moore has spent an offseason sharpening an identity without Jim Harbaugh’s shadow overhead. Michigan thrives in the role of hunter, not hunted, and this year they’re hunting redemption.
The playoff path: Beat Ohio State at home. Everything else falls into place. A one-loss Michigan with a rivalry win is automatic playoff fuel.
Florida Gators (SEC)
The Swamp hasn’t felt like the center of college football in over a decade, but 2025 brings renewed hope. QB DJ Lagway, the highest-rated recruit in program history, is ready to unleash his dual-threat fireworks. Billy Napier’s tenure has been rocky, but an improved defense and a schedule that includes statement opportunities (Georgia, Texas, LSU) gives Florida the kind of visibility that Heisman voters and CFP committee members love.
The playoff path: If Lagway delivers on his five-star promise and Florida rides the SEC chaos wave to 10 wins, the Gators could finally return to the national stage.
Oklahoma Sooners (SEC)
The Sooners were supposed to struggle in their SEC baptism, but Oklahoma still packs tradition, talent, and swagger. Transfer John Mateer looks to bring a spark to this Sooners offense while the defense, hardened by the physical grind of SEC play, looks prepared to carry its weight. Brent Venables knows his program can’t just survive in the SEC—it has to thrive.
The playoff path: A couple of high-profile upsets—think Alabama or Texas—and Oklahoma becomes impossible to ignore. With the SEC guaranteed a spot, the Sooners have as clear a road as anyone.
The poetry of possibility
The favorites will always command the spotlight. They draw the hype, the preseason polls, and the endless debate shows. But every fall, college football reminds us why we watch: because order bends, giants stumble, and dark horses rise.
- Arizona State is the desert storm.
- Illinois is the iron wall.
- Michigan is redemption.
- Florida is the roar of the Swamp.
- Oklahoma is tradition re-forged in SEC fire.
In the 2025 season, these five programs could be the ones to storm through cracked open gates of playoff expansion.
Don’t blink. The chaos is coming.
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL NEWS:
- Heisman heat index: Contenders, pretenders, odds before 2025 college football season
- 10 loudest college football stadiums ranked
- LSU leans on Garrett Nussmeier — can he thrive with new offensive support?
- Texas will lean on Arch Manning, can he lead the Longhorns past key departures?
- Frank Reich sets tone as Stanford heads to Hawaii